« Washington, DC | Main | The Knights Templar and the Rowan Williams crisis »

11 February 2008

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341c34b553ef00e5502b3ea78833

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Williams and Shariah:

Comments

Yunus

I've been deeply saddened by the whole debacle, frankly. Quite a few Muslim bloggers ran to the speech and then sat down to demonstrate how much they knew about the Shariah compared to the broadsheet media. But the media furore was in response to the Radio 4 interview, which I listened to, and almost wept as Williams ran like a poodle into the jaws of the rapacious journalist sat before him. The tabloid response was inevitable and I think some have been a little slow to appreciate how vile some of that has been, and the potential backlash such headlines provoke on the street. The Sun is read by 8 million people a day. Some of the more self-important among us need to wake up to that reality.

aineliva

Perhaps he made it to stimulate debate, mostly for the population affected and disinformed, and scared by newspaper articles etc. He should be applauded; but then what is interesting is the legions of objectors who suddenly appeared from nowhere to raise objections, claim offense has been caused and get media attention for their idea of "social cohesion", e.g. the guy on Newsnight. It seems that these individuals and organisations exist everywhere.

Kathleen

Well maybe it is about time we had some Shariah law implemented in our corrupt and depraved society.
All too often murderers, paedophiles and rapists walk free from court or get reduced sentences and are free to reoffend.
Parents, schools and the Government seem to be incapable of doing anything about youth crime, teenage pregnancy, knife culture and under age drinking.
At least in countries where Shariah law is imposed criminals are punished and not the victims.
Living in the Middle East for 4 years I never felt threatened going out alone in my car or walking at night, something I can not say about Scotland and Britain.

MLS

With regard to the Archbishop`s remarks. what he is suggesting, or rather exploring, is what lots of other countries already have in place. Lets take Egypt as an example.In the Egyptian Legal system matters that relates to Family Laws ie, marriage, divorce, custody, inheritance, and any other dispute relating to the family, are assigned to the "Sect Court" or what is known as the "Majlis Milli". Meaning, if an Egyptian christian catholic wants to divorce his wife, they then go to a Catholic Family Law Judge , and Egyptian Muslims"95 %" go to the Share ea Court.. The Share ea Courts , in Egypt, are proper courts, they are not like the courts that the BBC, put on the screen to scare people.However, the "Sect Court" does not handle any matters relating to Criminal Law, and it`s boundaries remain within the family issues where the State has no power to prosecute or start any proceeding without a family member bringing the issue to the State`s attention, and request their help.

Ted Harvey

Hmm... I can't see how this type of highly contentious and constestable comment is going to help anything in what is an already sensitive situation:

"Well maybe it is about time we had some Shariah law implemented in our corrupt and depraved society".

As for:

"Living in the Middle East for 4 years I never felt threatened going out alone in my car or walking at night"

I'm not especiably knowlegeable about the whole of the Middle East, but I reckon there are some pretty substantial chunks of it where women (or indeed anyone)would not be safe going out walking at night.

The comments to this entry are closed.

My Photo

Buttons



View Osama Saeed's profile on LinkedIn

Feeds


  • Subscribe in Bloglines

    Subscribe in NewsGator Online

    Add to Google


  • Enter your email address:

    Get alerts of new posts